Source: sideshowtoy.com
1. Zatanna
(Batman, Justice League Dark, DC Comics)
I loves me some magic DC characters. Zatanna Zatara wasn't just a contender for the "Jesus, why do both of my names have to be weird as hell" award, she was also the child of Golden Age hero Zatara and Homo Magi representative Sindella. I guess names the professor never remembers how to spell run in the family.
Her power was the ability to use that cool backward-talking magic that works so well in comics, but really nowhere else. She also mind-wiped a bunch of her friends, like a major jerk-hole. She balanced using her magic for superheroing and using it as a stage magician.
But I feel like being a known witch would hurt your ticket sales. Like, I thought half the appeal of magic shows was "How did they do it?" Doesn't it kind of ruin the thing if you know the answer is "Oh, she did it with magic. Like real magic. Which she knows. She’s in the Justice League, and uses magic to decimate alien spaceships on the regular. I don't find it very impressive that she made that rabbit disappear."
And there you have it. Ten wizards, warlocks, and charlatans for you to peruse. Hopefully, you’ll find at least one you like. Oh, and your card? It was the Ace of Clubs. I think.

