Disney announced a few years ago that the fans would get a new Star Wars movie each year for the foreseeable future. Of the main trilogy, The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi have already been released, as has the Rogue One spin-off. And while some of the projects that are waiting to be released have encountered some production problems (Han Solo lost its directors in the middle of production, and the Star Wars: Episode IX director was fired), the future still looks bright.

It looks especially bright when you consider that a new trilogy that reportedly isn’t about the Skywalkers has already been announced.

So far, eight main-saga Star Wars movies have been released, along with a couple of spin-offs. Looking back, which of the films in release have made us even more hopeful for the future? In other words, which Star Wars movies were actually great, and which disappointed?